Most people compare the avalanche vs snowball method when several balances are open at once and a monthly budget has just been set, which is also the moment they are least able to tell whether the arithmetic or the motivation should decide the order.

This page sets out exactly what a debt payoff calculator computes under each method: how each one orders debts, how a month’s interest and payment are applied, how a freed-up minimum rolls into the next debt, and how rounding is handled before a payoff date is shown. Then it runs one worked example so you can rerun the arithmetic yourself, and it lists the assumptions the answer rests on, including the one most tools hide, which is that rates and minimum payments stay the same until each debt is gone.

A rate is a fact with a date. This page does not quote any rate, balance or payoff time. Every figure in your comparison is your input, not ours, and the source for each one is your latest statement from that lender, with its date.

This is general information, not financial advice. It is not medical advice either. Check any figure against the source named on the page.

How each method orders debts

Both methods share the same routine. Only the order changes.

  1. List every debt with its balance, interest rate and minimum payment, copied from each statement.
  2. Set a total monthly amount you can put toward debt.
  3. Pay the minimum on every debt.
  4. Put whatever is left over toward one target debt.
  5. When the target debt is paid off, add its minimum payment to the extra amount and move to the next debt in the order.

The order is the only difference:

  • Avalanche: order debts from highest interest rate to lowest.
  • Snowball: order debts from smallest balance to largest.

If the debt with the highest rate also has the smallest balance, both methods start in the same place. The difference only appears when the two orders disagree.

Our debt payoff calculator lets you enter your own debts and see the order and the payoff schedule under each method.

The calculation for one month

Here is the formula a simple monthly model applies to each debt:

Interest for the month = balance × annual rate / 12

New balance = balance + interest for the month − payment

The payment is the minimum, plus the extra amount if this debt is the current target. Your statements say how each lender actually charges interest; if a lender works it out daily, the monthly model is an approximation, and the statement is the source to check against.

Worked example with three example balances

This walk-through uses your own debts, or three example debts you invent to test the method. Treat every figure as an example, not as a typical balance or rate.

  1. Make a table with one row per debt and columns for balance, rate, minimum payment and order.
  2. Sort the table twice: once by rate, highest first, for the avalanche order; once by balance, smallest first, for the snowball order.
  3. Work out the month’s interest for each debt with the formula above.
  4. Apply one month of payments in each order: the minimum on everything, the extra on the target.
  5. Update each balance with the new-balance formula.
  6. Repeat month by month in a spreadsheet until every balance reaches zero. When one debt reaches zero, roll its minimum into the extra for the next target.
  7. Add up the interest paid under each order.
  8. Note the month each debt was cleared under each order.
  9. Compare your spreadsheet with our calculator. They should match, or differ only in rounding.

The spreadsheet does the repetitive part. The comparison at the end is the part worth reading slowly.

What happens to the minimum you free up

Both methods depend on one step that is easy to skip: when a debt is cleared, its old minimum payment joins the extra amount aimed at the next debt. If the freed-up minimum is spent instead, the plan slows down under either order, and the comparison between the two stops meaning much. Setting the total monthly debt payment as one fixed amount makes the roll-over happen without a new decision each time.

Total interest under each method

Your spreadsheet answers this question for your own debts, and we do not quote a typical difference. What to look for when you compare the two totals:

  • Which order pays less total interest with your figures.
  • Which order clears its first debt sooner with your figures.
  • How large the gap between the two totals is. If your rates are close together, it may be small.

Run your own figures before you choose.

The behavioural argument

The case for the snowball method is about people, not arithmetic: clearing a whole debt early on may feel like progress, and some people find that helps them stick with a plan. The case for the avalanche method is that it follows the rates. Neither is right for everyone. A few questions may help you decide:

  • Have you started a payoff plan before and stopped? If so, an early win may matter more to you.
  • Is the interest gap between the two orders large or small with your own figures?
  • Would a hybrid work, such as clearing one very small balance first and then switching to the avalanche order?

When to talk to a nonprofit credit counselor

Both methods assume you can pay at least the minimum on every debt each month. If that is not true, a payoff order is not the first problem to solve. It may be worth talking to a nonprofit credit counselor when:

  • you are missing minimum payments or paying late;
  • debt payments leave too little for essentials;
  • a debt has gone to collections;
  • you are being offered debt relief or settlement and are not sure what it involves.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Ask CFPB pages explain how credit counseling works and what to ask before choosing an organisation, and its debt collection pages cover what to do when a debt is in collections. We do not name or recommend any debt relief company.

Risks to understand

This assumes rates, minimums and balances follow your statements, with no new borrowing. Check each assumption against your own accounts:

  • Find out whether each rate is fixed or variable, and whether a promotional rate ends.
  • Check whether a minimum payment changes as the balance changes.
  • New borrowing during the plan changes every row.
  • Fees and charges are not in the formula. Read each account’s terms for them.
  • A payoff date from any calculator is arithmetic on your inputs, not a promise.

Questions to ask your lender or adviser

  1. What is the current rate on this debt, and is it fixed or variable?
  2. Is there a promotional rate, and when does it end?
  3. How is interest calculated: daily, monthly or another way?
  4. If I pay more than the minimum, how is the extra applied?
  5. Are there any fees for paying early or changing my payment?

For decisions about borrowing or managing debt, ask a qualified professional who can look at your whole situation.

A quick checklist before you start

  • List every debt with balance, rate and minimum from its latest statement.
  • Confirm you can pay every minimum each month.
  • Run both orders with your own figures.
  • Choose an order and write down why.
  • Roll each freed-up minimum into the next debt.
  • Recheck rates and balances against new statements every few months.

The related question: what about consolidating?

Some people compare a payoff order with moving several debts into one new loan or balance transfer. That changes the rates, the fees and the term, so it is a different calculation. If you are weighing that option, run the new loan through our loan amortization calculator, add any fees from the offer to the balance, and compare its total cost with your own avalanche and snowball totals. Then take all three figures to a qualified adviser.

Further reading

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, consumerfinance.gov: debt, credit cards, credit counseling and debt collection.

Federal Reserve, federalreserve.gov: consumer resources on credit.

We do not currently have an affiliate relationship with any service mentioned here. If that changes, we will say so in the piece that contains the link.

This is general information, not financial advice. It is not medical advice either. Check any figure against the source named on the page.

Expert Calculators Editorial