The refinance break-even point is the month when the money saved by a new loan has added up to the cost of getting that loan. Most people meet a refinance calculator the moment a lender quotes a lower payment, which is also the moment they are least able to tell whether the two loans are being compared on the same basis.
This page sets out exactly what a refinance break-even calculation computes: the formula, the two inputs it needs and where to find them on a lender’s documents. Then it runs one worked example with the arithmetic shown so you can rerun it yourself, and it lists the assumptions the answer rests on, including the one most tools hide, which is that the new term is no longer than what remains on the old loan.
A rate is a fact with a date. This page does not quote any interest rate or fee as current, and it does not tell you whether to refinance. Every figure in the example is a labelled example, and every figure you enter is your input, not ours. The document names used here are the United States ones; currency is left unstated because the arithmetic is the same in any currency.
This is general information, not financial advice. It is not medical advice either. Check any figure against the source named on the page.
We do not currently have an affiliate relationship with any service mentioned here. If that changes, we will say so in the piece that contains the link.
Here is the formula
The calculation is: break-even months equals total closing costs divided by monthly saving.
- Add up the total closing costs of the new loan.
- Work out the monthly saving: the current principal and interest payment minus the new principal and interest payment.
- Divide the total closing costs by the monthly saving. The result is in months. Divide by twelve for years.
If the monthly saving is zero or negative, there is no break-even point on this measure. A refinance that raises the monthly payment, for example to shorten the term, has to be judged on total cost instead.
The two inputs and where they come from
- Closing costs. Everything you pay to take out the new loan, as itemised on the lender’s written estimate. Check whether the estimate shows lender fees, third-party charges and any points you choose to pay. Ask whether any cost is being rolled into the loan instead of charged upfront, because you still pay it, just over time and with interest.
- Monthly saving. The old payment minus the new payment, compared on the same basis. If one figure includes taxes and insurance held in escrow and the other does not, the comparison is wrong before it starts.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s owning a home resources explain the standard loan documents in the United States, including the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure. Those documents are the right place to get your inputs, not an advertisement or a verbal quote.
Worked example with example figures
These are example figures only, chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow. They are not a quote, a typical cost or a current rate.
- Example closing costs on the new loan: 3,000.
- Example current principal and interest payment: 1,250 a month.
- Example new principal and interest payment: 1,100 a month.
- Monthly saving: 1,250 minus 1,100 equals 150.
- Break-even: 3,000 divided by 150 equals 20 months, which is one year and eight months.
Check it yourself the other way: 150 a month for 20 months is 3,000, which matches the closing costs. Now replace each example figure with the one on your own statement and Loan Estimate, and run it again. Then get a second Loan Estimate from another lender and compare the two results side by side.
How to use a refinance calculator
Our refinance calculator runs this comparison. To use it well:
- Start with your current loan statement. Note the remaining balance, the current rate, the remaining term and the principal and interest part of the payment.
- Use a written estimate for the new loan. Enter the rate, term and total closing costs from the lender’s document, not from memory.
- Compare like with like. Make sure both payments are principal and interest only, or both include the same escrow items.
- Read the break-even months. This is the time it takes for savings to cover costs, under the tool’s assumptions.
- Compare with how long you expect to keep the loan. If you are likely to sell or refinance again before break-even, the switch may cost more than it saves.
- Look at total interest as well. A lower payment over a longer term can mean paying more interest overall.
If the calculator and your hand calculation differ, check whether the tool included or excluded points, whether it used the same payment basis, and whether it rounded.
This assumes
- Both payments are compared on the same basis, principal and interest only.
- Closing costs are paid upfront, not added to the balance.
- The monthly saving stays the same every month, which holds for a fixed rate but not for an adjustable one.
- The new term is no longer than what remains on the old loan.
- You keep the new loan at least until the break-even month.
When this breaks down
The basic break-even figure is a useful first filter. It can mislead when one of the assumptions above fails:
- Term reset. If you are some years into a loan and refinance into a new full-length term, a lower payment may come from stretching repayment out, not from a better deal. Total interest paid may rise.
- Costs rolled into the loan. If closing costs are added to the balance, you pay interest on them, which pushes the real break-even later.
- Rate type changes. Moving from a fixed rate to an adjustable one, or the reverse, changes your risk in a way a break-even figure cannot show.
- Opportunity cost. Money paid upfront in closing costs is money not available for other uses.
- Tax questions. Whether interest or points affect your tax position depends on your situation and jurisdiction. That is a question for a tax professional, not for this formula.
A fuller check is to compare total remaining interest on the old loan with total interest on the new one, alongside the break-even months.
Refinance break-even point: questions to answer first
- How long do I realistically expect to keep this loan or this property?
- Am I comparing principal and interest only, on both sides?
- Are closing costs paid upfront or added to the loan?
- Is the new term longer than what remains on my current loan?
- What is the total interest on each option, not only the monthly payment?
- Does my current loan have any prepayment penalty?
Common mistakes
- Using a payment that includes escrow on one side and excludes it on the other.
- Leaving points or some fees out of the closing costs.
- Ignoring the effect of restarting the term.
- Relying on an advertised rate instead of a written estimate for your situation.
- Comparing only one lender’s offer.
- Treating the break-even figure as the whole decision.
Ask a qualified professional
A refinance calculator works with the figures you give it. It does not know whether you will qualify, what your credit history allows, how property values may move, or whether you might need to sell sooner than you think. A mortgage refinance also uses your home as security for the new loan.
Stop and talk to a qualified professional, such as a housing counsellor, a financial adviser or the lender in writing, if:
- You are considering taking cash out of your home equity.
- You are switching between fixed and adjustable rates.
- You are behind on payments or worried about keeping up.
- The figures you have been quoted are hard to reconcile with each other.
Questions worth putting to a lender in writing:
- Can you give me a written Loan Estimate with all closing costs itemised?
- Are any costs being added to the loan balance rather than paid at closing?
- What is the total interest I would pay over the full term of this loan?
- Is there a prepayment penalty on the new loan or my current one?
- How would the payment change if the rate is adjustable?
The related question: what about the amortization schedule?
A refinance starts a new amortization schedule, which is why the share of each payment going to interest may jump back up after a switch. Our loan amortization calculator shows how that schedule works for any loan you enter.
Further reading
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (consumerfinance.gov): explanations of mortgage documents, costs and refinancing.
- Federal Reserve (federalreserve.gov): background on interest rates and consumer credit.
- SEC Investor.gov (investor.gov): financial education resources, including compounding and interest.
This is general information, not financial advice. It is not medical advice either. Check any figure against the source named on the page.
Expert Calculators Editorial